Skip to contents

Rank decision options by criteria weighted by the people you asked.

The example in this guide is Choosing next year’s venue. A decision study choosing next year’s venue from candidate venues, weighting the criteria and ranking the venues by 10 methods.

In SurveyStudio

  1. In RStudio, open the Addins menu, choose surveyframe: Try a demo and pick mcdm_choice.
  2. On Design, see the criteria weight question and the 2 pairwise comparison questions, 1 on Saaty’s importance scale and 1 on the influence scale.
  3. On Design, choose Plan. RQ1 to RQ3 derive the criteria weights (AHP, ANP) and their influence on each other (DEMATEL). RQ4 to RQ10 rank the venues with those weights by 7 ranking methods.
  4. On Analyse, run the plan and check the consistency ratio before using the weights.
The Design screen with the Choosing next year’s venue study open.
The Design screen with the Choosing next year’s venue study open.

In R

d <- sframe_demo("mcdm_choice")
results <- run_analysis_plan(d$responses, d$instrument)

The research questions and what the report gives

Research question Method What the report gives
What weight does each criterion carry? Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
What weight does each criterion carry when network dependence is allowed? Analytic network process (ANP) The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which criteria drive the others? DEMATEL The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks best overall? TOPSIS The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks highest by compromise ranking? VIKOR The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks highest by ratio analysis? MOORA The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks highest by simple multi-attribute rating? SMART The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks highest by weighted aggregated sum product? WASPAS The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks highest by outranking flows? PROMETHEE The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one
Which venue ranks highest by outranking with thresholds? ELECTRE The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one

Run the example in SurveyStudio or R to see the results, each marked as demonstration data.