How to choose between options on multiple criteria
Source:vignettes/articles/guides/choose-between-options-on-multiple-criteria.Rmd
choose-between-options-on-multiple-criteria.RmdRank decision options by criteria weighted by the people you asked.
The example in this guide is Choosing next year’s venue. A decision study choosing next year’s venue from candidate venues, weighting the criteria and ranking the venues by 10 methods.
In SurveyStudio
- In RStudio, open the Addins menu, choose
surveyframe: Try a demo and pick
mcdm_choice. - On Design, see the criteria weight question and the 2 pairwise comparison questions, 1 on Saaty’s importance scale and 1 on the influence scale.
- On Design, choose Plan. RQ1 to RQ3 derive the criteria weights (AHP, ANP) and their influence on each other (DEMATEL). RQ4 to RQ10 rank the venues with those weights by 7 ranking methods.
- On Analyse, run the plan and check the consistency ratio before using the weights.

The Design screen with the Choosing next year’s
venue study open.
In R
d <- sframe_demo("mcdm_choice")
results <- run_analysis_plan(d$responses, d$instrument)The research questions and what the report gives
| Research question | Method | What the report gives |
|---|---|---|
| What weight does each criterion carry? | Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| What weight does each criterion carry when network dependence is allowed? | Analytic network process (ANP) | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which criteria drive the others? | DEMATEL | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks best overall? | TOPSIS | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks highest by compromise ranking? | VIKOR | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks highest by ratio analysis? | MOORA | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks highest by simple multi-attribute rating? | SMART | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks highest by weighted aggregated sum product? | WASPAS | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks highest by outranking flows? | PROMETHEE | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
| Which venue ranks highest by outranking with thresholds? | ELECTRE | The APA 7 sentence and a table, with a chart where the method has one |
Run the example in SurveyStudio or R to see the results, each marked as demonstration data.